It takes a lot of work to get a home ready to sell. You may have spent weeks making small repairs, deep cleaning, decluttering and doing thoughtful staging to each room before your listing went live on the MLS and you opened the doors to the first potential buyers.
When the housing market in your area is hot, all that effort may suddenly pay off with a flurry of offers that all roll in within hours or days of each other. In all the excitement, it can be incredibly tempting to zero in on the highest number and accept that bid without another thought.
Take a deep breath and hold on. When it comes to real estate sales, the strongest offer you get may not be the one with the biggest dollar amount attached. Sellers are wise to take a closer look at the bids they receive, because a careful approach can let you walk away with a better deal – one that will ultimately have a smoother, more reliable path to closing.
Before accepting any offer, it is worth slowing down, talking to your REALTOR® and looking at the details behind a bid.
Price Is Only One Piece of the Puzzle
The price of an offer is, quite naturally, the hook that grabs you, but price alone does not always tell the full story behind the bid. A high offer can come with strings attached that diminish its true value.
In some cases, a high initial offer is just a strategic ploy to secure the contract before another buyer has a chance. Some buyers submit aggressive offers to win bidding wars, especially in a hot market, only to renegotiate later after the inspections or appraisals are done. Others may not actually have the financial backing to support the number they put down on paper, making their bid “optimistic,” at best. The buyer may gamble that the seller will ultimately be willing to make concessions down the line rather than start the whole process over.
Look beyond the dollar amount of a bid and evaluate the full picture, including how likely an offer is to close the deal. You need to be particularly cautious about offers that seem unrealistic, inflated or rushed.
Financing Matters More Than You Think
One of the most important factors in any offer is how the buyer plans to pay for the home. Not all financing is created equally, and the type of loan a buyer needs can affect both the timeline of the sale and the level of risk to the seller.
Sellers should carefully review whether the buyer is:
- Paying in cash, which typically allows for a faster and more predictable closing
- Using conventional financing, which is generally predictable and straightforward
- Relying on FHA or VA loans, which may include stricter property requirements and appraisal conditions that can prove complicated
It is also worth looking at the strength of the buyer’s pre-approval. A fully underwritten pre-approval carries a lot more weight than a basic pre-qualification, which is speculative and more likely to move to closing without issues.
A slightly lower offer backed by strong financing or cash can often be more dependable than a higher offer that depends on multiple approvals and several contingencies.
Contingencies Can Change Everything
Contingencies are, in essence, conditions in the contract that must be met for a sale to move forward. While they are common and usually reasonable, too many contingencies can signal future trouble. An offer with fewer contingencies indicates a committed buyer.
Common contingencies include:
- Home inspection
- Appraisal
- Financing approval
- Sale of the buyer’s current home
Each contingency is a potential exit point for the buyer. An offer loaded with contingencies carries more opportunities for the deal to fall apart or be renegotiated, no matter how attractive the dollar amount of the bid. On the other hand, a cleaner offer with fewer contingencies may provide greater certainty, even if the purchase price is slightly lower.
Also, pay attention to how contingencies are written. If a seller is willing to limit their repair requests, offer an inspection-for-information-only clause or shorten the timeline to closing, that can make their offer stronger.
Earnest Money Shows a Level of Commitment
Earnest money is the buyer’s “good faith” deposit on a home. Most people know that handing over earnest money is a signal from the buyer that they’re serious about their bid. However, earnest money is also an insurance policy for the seller. If the buyer backs out without a valid reason under the contract (usually under a contingency clause), they forfeit that money to compensate the seller for taking the home off the market in the meantime.
Earnest money deposits can be influenced by local customs and the intensity of the market, but they generally range from 1% to 5% of the sale price. A buyer who offers 5% (or more) is putting a meaningful amount on the table. They have a lot more to lose than a buyer who is only willing to put down 1%.
Do not overlook this detail when you are evaluating multiple bids. A buyer willing to commit more money upfront is naturally more invested in seeing the transaction through, and that can reduce the likelihood of unpleasant surprises.
Appraisal Gaps Can Be an Issue with Inflated Bids
In competitive markets, buyers sometimes offer more than the home is likely to be worth upon appraisal. When that happens, the deal can run into trouble if the lender will not support the full purchase price. This is called an “appraisal gap.”
Some buyers, knowing that they are making a larger-than-expected bid, will include an appraisal gap guarantee in their offer. This is an agreement to cover any difference between the appraised value and the offer price out of pocket, in cash.
Without that protection, a high offer may not survive the appraisal process, and the deal can fall apart. If a bid is higher than you were asking, look closely at whether the buyer has accounted for the possibility of an appraisal gap, and how.
Buyer Flexibility Can Be a Hidden Advantage
Not every advantage shows up in dollars. Sometimes, the most appealing offer is the one that fits a seller’s timeline and emotional needs.
Buyers who offer flexibility – such as a willingness to accommodate a seller’s preferred closing date, allowing a rent-back period or otherwise being agreeable about timing or other requests – can make the whole transition process for a seller much easier.
That kind of flexibility can reduce your stress and the emotional burden you’re under during a major transition, especially if you don’t already have your next home lined up.
The Strongest Offer Is the One That Closes
At the end of the day, the goal is to successfully close the sale of your home with as few complications as possible. Choosing the right offer is less about chasing the highest number and more about selecting the path that can bring you straight to closing day.
A strong offer balances price with reliability, financial backing, reasonable contingencies and a clear path forward. If you take the time to evaluate each bid you receive, you are far more likely to avoid trouble.
bill.ingram@talktotucker.combrad.layton@talktotucker.comeditors-pickerina.pribyshchuk@talktotucker.comfeaturedlloyd.zimmerman@talktotucker.commark.callahan@talktotucker.commary.layton@talktotucker.compriscila.hale@talktotucker.comterri.mcgraw@talktotucker.com
