Budget Friendly Valentines Engagement Ring

Local Indy Jewelry Stores

Are you wanting to surprise your loved one this Valentine’s Day with some sparkling new jewelry? If so, you’ve come to the right place! We have compiled a list of some of the best local jewelry shops around Indy that are sure to have that perfect piece of jewelry for that special someone.


J.C. Sipe – Indianapolis

This third generation, family owned jewelry store specializes in fine diamonds, estate jewelry, engagement rings as well as custom designed, hand drawn and hand carved jewelry that is all done on-site.  They have been dedicated to providing excellent service and amazing jewelry for 135 years! If you are looking for something that will really stand out, they also offer gold and platinum plated, real roses! How cool is that!?


McGee & Co Jewelers  – Greenwood

This family owned jeweler has served Indianapolis for 31 years and they strive to provide unsurpassed customer service and high quality fine jewelry. They have everything you need from diamond engagement rings, wedding bands, anniversary rings, to watches and fashion jewelry.


Aronstam Fine Jewelers – Carmel

If you’re really looking for something different and unique, this is the place to go. This is a small romantic gallery where Marc Aronstam creates custom pieces to express the personality or the memories of the jewelry owner, or the love story of the couple. At Aronstam, you are sure to find a one-of-a-kind piece for your loved one that they will cherish for years to come.


Moyer Fine Jewelry – Carmel

Moyer Fine Jewelry in Carmel is known for having many of the nations top designer brands and knowledgeable service provided by their staff. They have an assortment of both classic, timeless pieces and trendy, stylish pieces. Moyer Fine Jewelers offers a generous refund and exchange policy, as well as 0% financing options and a lifetime guarantee on all its fine jewelry.


J.L. Johnson – Greenwood

Located on the south side of Indy, for 26 years J.L. Johnson has been offering great jewelry at affordable prices. If it is an engagement ring you’re looking for, they have some of the best diamonds to fit your budget, and if you can’t find exactly what you are looking for, they will design it for you! They know that the jewelry you select will be a personal promise of your love for a lifetime and they have a great passion for making special and custom pieces for their customers.


Windsor Jewelry – Indianapolis

Windsor has been serving Indy for almost 100 years and the employees have worked there for an average of 20 years, so when you go in you are sure to know someone and always feel at home!  They specialize in engagement and wedding rings, diamonds, watches, earrings, necklaces, gemstones, and more. Windsor also has an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and people speak very highly of the staff and their helpful attitude as well as their expertise. 


Smith’s Jewelers – Noblesville

Smith’s Jewelers specializes in custom designed jewelry, bridal and engagement rings, diamonds, and watches. They also have a great selection of earrings, bracelets and necklaces. There are various financing and layaway options are available to customers, and the store also offers full refund and exchange policies. 


Robert Goodman Jewelers– Zionsville

This is a true, local mom and pop shop, where you can expect honesty and sincerity in your jewelry search. Their priority is to treat everyone as equals, to never make an assumption about anyone that walks in their store and to help everyone in the exact same way.  On top of that, you will find some amazing, one-of-a-kind jewelry and stunning collections that you won’t find anywhere else.


Diamonds Direct – Indianapolis

This store is one of the leading bridal jewelers in Indianapolis, where it boasts a 5,500 square foot showroom. They carry over 50 designers and over 3,000 engagement ring mountings in their store. They also offer a lifetime warranty, free delivery, financing options and much more.


Reis-Nichols – Indianapolis

Reis-Nichols offers the largest selection of jewelry in the city. They have a huge variety of rings, watches, earrings, bracelets, and necklaces all at amazing prices, backed by a lifetime and money back guarantee. They have been family owned and operated since 1919 and hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.


JL Hupp – Fishers

This is a reputable jewelry store in Fishers that offers a vast selection of diamonds and precious stone rings for any occasion.  They offer rings, earrings, watches, and custom jewelry designs, as well as an impressive collection of antique and estate jewelry. They have been around since 1977 and the staff really knows their stuff!